
ServicesRoof Repair
Roof Repair in Cumberland, IN
Most leaks start at a small detail: a cracked pipe boot, a loose piece of flashing, a nail that backed out. We track down where the water really gets in, fix that spot properly, and walk you through pictures from the roof before and after.
Small fixes, done carefully
A good repair is mostly about the parts you never see. Flashing has to lap the right way so water runs over it, not behind it. New shingles need to be nailed in the right zone and tucked under the old ones so the wind can't lift them. Skip those steps and the same leak comes back next spring.
Repair is the right call when the roof deck is solid and the damage sits in one area. If we find soft decking across a whole slope, or shingles worn out everywhere, we'll tell you straight and explain when roof replacement costs less than patching again and again. Most of the time, a careful repair is all your home needs.
Our crew is licensed for this work, and we're bonded and insured on every job, small repairs included.
What a roof repair includes
- Leak tracing
- We start in the attic when we can, looking for stains, wet insulation and daylight. Then we follow the path up to the roof. Water often gets in a few feet uphill from where the drip shows on your ceiling.
- Flashing and counterflashing
- At chimneys, walls and skylights we weave step flashing in with each shingle course and set counterflashing over it. Caulk alone is not a fix. It shrinks and pulls away within a few seasons.
- Pipe boots and vents
- Rubber boots around plumbing vents crack in the sun. They are one of the most common leaks we find. We replace them and keep the nails hidden under the shingle above, not left bare on top.
- Shingle replacement
- We break the seal on the course above without tearing it, slide new shingles in and hand-nail them in the nail line. As an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, we install to the manufacturer's instructions on a small repair the same as on a full roof.
- Soft decking
- If the plywood under a leak has gone soft, we cut out the bad section and fasten new decking to the rafters before any shingles go back down. Patching over rot only hides it.
Signs your roof needs a repair
A stain on the ceiling
A brown ring that grows after each rain means water is getting through. It won't fix itself, and the wet insulation above it stops keeping heat in.
Shingles in the yard
After a strong wind, check the grass and the driveway. One missing tab leaves nails and underlayment open to the weather. If a big storm came through, our Storm Damage Repair page covers claims and hail damage.
Heavy granules in the gutters
Fresh shingles shed some grit in their first year, and that's fine. Drifts of granules washing off an older roof tell you the shingles have worn thin in places.
Water near a chimney or skylight
Leaks around these almost always point to flashing. Some only show up in a driving rain from one direction, so note when you see them.
Water at the eaves in winter
Freeze-thaw winters build ice dams along the edge of the roof. Water backs up under the shingles and shows up on the inside of outside walls. We repair the damage and check whether ice and water shield is in place.
How a repair visit goes
- 1
Free inspection
You call, we pick a time, and we look over the roof and the attic. We photograph everything we find. This visit costs you nothing.
- 2
Written estimate
We put every repair on paper as its own item with its own cost. If something can wait a year, we say so. Financing is available if you'd rather spread out the payments.
- 3
Repair day
We lay tarps over plants and walkways and work one section at a time, so your roof is never left open. Most repairs are done in a day.
- 4
Cleanup and photos
Before we leave, we sweep the grass and drive with a magnetic roller to pick up stray nails, and the old shingles and flashing go in our truck. Then we sit down with you and go over the before-and-after photos.

What moves the price of a roof repair
We can't put a number on a repair until we've been up there, so the free inspection comes first. Two ceiling stains that look the same can come from very different problems on the roof. Each repair gets its own line on the written estimate, so nothing is lumped together.
- How much is damaged
- Swapping one pipe boot is a short job. A torn patch running across several shingle courses takes more material and more hours.
- Flashing work
- Rebuilding step flashing and counterflashing at a chimney takes longer than most repairs, more so when mortar joints have to be cut and resealed.
- What's under the shingles
- Soft decking adds plywood and labor. Sometimes we can't see it until the shingles come up, so we talk through that chance before we start.
- Pitch and access
- Steep slopes need roof jacks and extra safety setup. Tight spots next to a second story take longer to work safely.
Roof repair questions
Something not covered here? (317) 743-3417
Can't you just put sealant on the leak?
Sealant works on an exposed nail head or as a short-term stopgap. It won't fix bad flashing or a torn shingle. Hot summers and cold winters dry it out until it cracks. We replace the part that failed instead.
Will a patched spot stand out from the rest of the roof?
We bring shingles in the closest color and profile we can find for your roof. Older shingles have faded in the sun, so the new ones look a little brighter for a while. Give them a season or two and the difference fades.
Should I repair or replace my roof?
If the damage sits in one area and the rest of the roof still has years in it, repair it. If shingles are curling on every slope, or you've had several leaks in a few years, roof replacement is usually the better spend. We show you the photos and you make the call.
Can you repair a roof in the winter?
Yes, on dry days above freezing we can do most repairs. Shingles get stiff in the cold, so we handle them carefully and hand-seal tabs that won't stick down on their own until spring. If a leak can't wait for a good day, we can cover the spot until we come back.
Do you repair roofs outside Cumberland?
Yes. We also work in Lawrence, New Palestine, Greenfield, Beech Grove, McCordsville and nearby towns. The Service Areas page lists the rest.

Let's find where the water is getting in
We'll check the roof and the attic, take photos and tell you what we'd fix. The inspection is free, and you'll have a written estimate before any work starts.